The Smart Aleck

In Shakespeare’s Sonnet, he appears to demoralize a woman because she is not the exact way he thinks a true woman should act. Although he expresses his love for her and her” imperfections,” he only states this at the very end and comes to a summarized statement stating that “yeah she has a bunch of flaws and is very “DULL,” but I still love her. “

After re-reading the poem several times and watching the video, the skit enhanced the poem entirely. In the poem Shakespeare wrote, his sonnet describes her as dull, but I’d like to think Catherine’s depiction was of a schoolgirl with a sharp mouth, who might see her as the class clown. She was very fierce and did not back down. Instead, she tried challenging the teacher for the fun of it. Although she might have been perceived as a nuisance, she was nowhere near dull. When I think of the word fierce, I associate it with red. Because being ferocious is an intense emotion that would resonate with a more vibrant tone, although she was joking around and not severe in Catherine’s skit, she showed an understanding of Shakespeare despite her being a smart aleck; she recited it with much passion, which shocked the teacher himself. In Shakespeare’s sonnet, it’s as if there is still some love behind all the imperfections. He is stating regardless of her imperfections he loves her regardless. I think it could be seen as a slight shift in interpretation. At the end of the skit, the teacher turns her into an action figure, which doesn’t equate to love because it portrays an annoyance on his end. At the same time, this skit gave a visual representation of what Shakespeare saw in his eyes: someone deemed annoying, but you can’t help but love her because she also had intelligence. One line resonates significantly with me. Lines 8-10: “Than in the breath that from my mistress reeks./I love to hear her speak, yet well I know/That music hath a far more pleasing sound; I found this to resonate with the skit since Catherine was portraying a student with sharp muth giving the teacher a hard time, and this could be why he does not see her as goddesses because, especially given the time, it was men hated when a woman had a voice or a sharp mouth and relatively associated that trait as an unwanted woman.

Victoria Sasere

Shakespearean Sonnets Taught By Dr Who, Interpreted By An Annoying English Student

Shakespearean sonnets are taught to many different students around the world, I from first hand experience know that they have been teaching us about Shakespeare’s work since middle school. Many students are not the biggest fans of Shakespeare’s work, but we all know it and I can confidently say that even if you are not a fan of literature you would be able to recognize what a Shakespearean sonnet looks like in the Elizabethan teaching of English Literature.

The poem “My mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun,” sonnet 130 written by Shakespeare, we are introduced to a mistress which Shakespeare describe in an unorthodox fashion, he explains that “if snow bobwhite, why then her breast are dun,” “And in some perfumes is more delight Than in the breath that from my mistress reeks.” Instead of painting his mistress in a light that depicts her beauty and that make the reader think about her in an angelic way, he does the complete opposite and writes al about her flaws. And although Shakespeare decides to do the unconventional and write about his mistress’ flaws, we interpret it as a way to say that her mistress is REAL, that she is human and not perfect like a doll or in this case the sun.

In the poem Shakespeare chooses unconventional, he chooses not to write a poem that us received as your “normal” poem talking about the beauty of a woman. We also find unconventionality in the Catherine Tates’s classroom performance. In the video, Catherine Tete plays a student who is not well behaved, and does not depict the characteristics of a model student. Catherine has her character mock the teacher and say he reminds her of “Dr Who” or saying “I don’t think you’re qualified to teach is english” because the teacher is Scottish. However when the teacher has finally had enough of Catherine he threatens to fail he, she then surprises everyone by reciting “My mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun” a sonnet by William Shakespeare, as mentioned previously. She surprises even the teacher as nobody would expect this from a baldly behaved student with such a reputation, however is happened and she did it correctly, she know what a Shakespearean sonnet is by heart.

This is unconventional and I think in a way helps emphasize the unconventionality that Shakespeare goes for in his poem. Just like how it doesn’t seem normal for Shakespeare to write about loving a mistress who, according to the sonnet, is imperfect is so many harsh ways, writing about her in a way that makes her seem so awful, it doesn’t seem normal for such an awful and uncumbersome student would have the ability to recite a poem by Shakespeare. I also think that there is a better emphasis created on the sonnet by the fact that such an unorthodox student would recite such an unorthodox sonnet by heart, in my eyes this enhances the horribleness of the mistress and brings a stronger pull on the words that are written by Shakespeare.

Another thing that what was worth mentioning when comparing the video and Shakespeare’s sonnet would be the turning point, the volta, that is present in both the poem and the video. Because the poem is a Shakespearean sonnet then it is structure with 12 lines that allow for a narrative build ups and two final couplets that are a turning point in the poem. And just like in the poem, the video is structured in a very similar format with the most of the initial part of the video building a narrative of the dislike that the Catherine’s character has for reading and for Shakespeare, however in the last few lines of the videos she recite the poem and surprises everyone, bring a turning point to the video, a last clap-back and her professor is you will. The video is essentially structured as a sonnet.

Guadalupe Lemus