At first glance, Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130 appears to be a critique of conventional notions of beauty. The speaker compares his mistress to objects of nature and describes her in less-than-flattering terms, seemingly defying the typical poetic praise of a lover’s physical attributes. Instead of comparing her eyes to the sun or her lips to coral, he candidly admits her imperfections, stating “My mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun; Coral is far more red than her lips’ red”(lines 1-2). However, amidst this apparent criticism lies an affirmation of genuine love that transcends superficial appearances “And yet, by heaven, I think my love as rare As any she belied with false compare,’ suggests that despite the speaker’s unconventional description of his mistress, his love for her is authentic and rare.”
Enter Catherine Tate’s character, a student who disrupts a classroom setting with her exaggerated antics and unconventional behavior. On the surface, she may seem like nothing more than a nuisance, embodying the antithesis of scholarly engagement. However, as the sketch unfolds, it becomes evident that there is more to her character than meets the eye. In a brilliant twist, Tate’s performance suggests that despite her outward demeanor, the student possesses a keen understanding of Shakespeare’s sonnet and its underlying themes- Much like the speaker in the sonnet, who sees beyond traditional standards of beauty to appreciate the true essence of his mistress, the audience is invited to look beyond the facade of the disruptive student to uncover her unexpected depth.
Tate’s comedic delivery and unexpected moments of insight character challenge preconceived notions and stereotypes. Her character becomes a symbol-like figure for the idea that intelligence and wisdom can manifest in unexpected ways, even in those who may not conform to societal expectations. In this light, Tate’s performance enhances the essence of Shakespeare’s sonnet by highlighting the notion that true understanding and appreciation go beyond surface-level impressions. Just as the speaker’s love for his mistress is genuine and true despite her perceived flaws, the audience’s appreciation for the student’s intellect is deepened by her unexpected depth.
-Mustang Chang